1774 James Varnum
1776 Richard Fry
1797 Mica Whitmarsh
1801 William Greene
1807 David Pinnegar
1808 Ray Greene
1809 Benjamin Bateman
1811 Joseph Tillinghast
1812 Henry C. Turner
1814 Benjamin Brown
1815 James V. Turner
1816 Benjamin Brown
1821 William Pinnegar
1824 Daniel Greene
1828 Elihu Greene
1830 Lodowick W. Updike
1833 Daniel Greene
1834 John P. Roberts
1835 John G. Ladd
1836 Daniel B. Bartholic
1837 Daniel Greene

1838 George W. T. Allen
1845 John P. Roberts
1847 Benjamin L. Spencer
1848 William Bodfish
1856 John Wright
1861 Charles W. Greene
1862 Edwin H. Gardiner
1864 Lyman Himes
1866 Daniel A. Peirce
1870 Lyman Himes
1874 Warren D. Gardiner
1875 Lyman Himes
1878 Will E. Brown
1896 William Arnold Browning
1899 Will E. Brown
1901 Walter E. Harrington
1902 Thomas Allen
1909 John L. Waters
1915 Melville A. Newcombe
1924 Albert A. Hall
1933 Thomas A. Peck

1934 C. Edward Anderson
1936 Thomas Casey Greene
1951 George R. Hathaway
1956 Benjamin F. Tefft
1957 James W. Tingley, Jr.
1972 Gilbert A. Hempel
1979 Robert Allen Greene
1980 Warren F. Dietzel
1981 Elmer H. Palmer
1987 Robert N. Sheldon
1993 Kenneth W. Chirnside
1995 Manfred J. Bangert
1998 Richard L. H. Palmer
2005 Richard Sheryka
2006 Patrick F. Lavelle
2008 William C. Gorry
2011 Warren Kaye
2015 Paul Ferrara
2019 Warren Kaye